Trump wants to push
Iran to the point of no return
(Atta Kenare/AFP/Getty)
Of all the countries
in the world, Iran seems to be President Trump’s main squeeze — and not
in a good way. On Monday, his administration confirmed that it was ending the temporary
waivers it had granted a handful of countries so they could keep
importing Iranian oil while avoiding sanctions imposed by the White House on the Iranian oil industry. The decision caught energy markets and a
number of key American partners, many of whom had anticipated receiving
an additional extension on the waivers, off guard. Oil prices spiked to
six-month highs after the news was first reported by The
Washington Post on Sunday.
At a news conference, Secretary
of State Mike Pompeo justified the measure as a bid to further reduce
what leverage the Islamic Republic may have on the world stage. “The goal
remains simple: to deprive the outlaw regime of the funds it has used to
destabilize the Middle East,” he said, adding that
the United States wanted to bring Iranian oil exports “to zero."
That means tightening the screws and compelling some major importers of
Iranian oil — including China and India — to turn off the tap.
Now, it’s raising the stakes for
other major powers. “Any nation or entity interacting with Iran should do its diligence and err on the side of caution,” Pompeo warned. "The
risks are simply not going to be worth the benefits.”
But it’s not fully
clear whether the Trump administration has done its own due diligence. The
United States is probably banking on Saudi Arabia and other major oil producers to help offset the Iranian oil taken off the market. But energy
experts warned that may be a trickier proposition than it seems, and will
almost certainly jack up gas prices for the
average American.
“The Saudis, OPEC, and Russia
could cover for Iranian oil, but the market will be really tight, and
prices will increase significantly, as there will not be much spare
capacity left in the market for any potential additional supply
interruption,” Sara Vakhshouri, an Iranian oil expert, told Foreign Policy.
And the White House may see its
pressure tactics rebuffed by other regional powers. Tehran exports
roughly 1 million barrels of oil daily, half of which go to China. Other
nation seeking waivers include India, Turkey, South Korea and Japan —
all major trade partners of the United States that aren’t pleased with
Washington’s coercive tactics.
“Their compliance with the
eleventh-hour White House demand that they end purchases immediately of
Iranian oil or face U.S. financial sanctions will be difficult, if not
impossible, to achieve,” noted Gerald Feierstein,
senior vice president of the Middle East Institute.
Both Chinese and Turkish
officials issued strong statements decrying U.S. unilateral sanctions and indicated their desire to continue
doing business with the Iranians.
As for India, analysts suggested
it probably will continue purchasing a reduced amount through a rupee payment. Tanvi
Madan, a South Asia expert at the Brookings Institution, pointed to the
damage that may be done to ties between the world’s
largest democracies.
“These developments will
reinforce the very Indian instinct that American policymakers dislike: the
quest for strategic autonomy, which is in no small part based on a sense
that the [United States] is not a reliable partner and will not be
mindful of Indian interests,”
Trump’s hostility to
Iran has already antagonized allies
in Europe,
who are still trying to persuade Tehran to remain within the nuclear deal.
“We regret yesterday’s announcement by the United States not to renew oil
waivers,” Maria Belovas, spokeswoman for the European Union’s delegation
to the United States, told Today’s WorldView. She added that the decision
further “risks undermining" a nonproliferation agreement that’s
“critical for regional and global security.” The U.N.'s International
Atomic Energy Agency, Belovas noted, has already confirmed Iran’s
compliance with restrictions on its nuclear activities 14 times.
But the White House’s latest
steps make the task even harder. In a tweet, Peter
Westmacott, a former British ambassador to the United States, warned that
the canceling of the waivers would stoke “regional instability,” anger U.S.
partners, hurt both the Turkish and Iranian economies, and strengthen the
hand of Iranian hard-liners who want nothing more than Iran to adopt a more hostile pose against American pressure. That could include
restarting uranium enrichment and other activities barred under the terms
of the nuclear deal.
Tehran may take a more watchful
approach. “They’re not going to make a rash overreaction to this,” Ellie
Geranmayeh, of the European Council on Foreign Relations, told the Independent.
“They’ve already said they’re going to be in consultation with partners. It will take some time to determine how much oil Iran can sell through illicit networks or through some sort of a special state-sanctioned
mechanism.”
But critics of the
Trump administration argued that it wants to goad Iran into a fight.
Aaron David Miller and Richard Sokolsky, former State Department
officials who served in both Republican and Democratic administrations,
lamented what they see as this administration’s “pattern of relying on
coercion and intimidation rather than diplomacy” — tactics zealously
pursued by Pompeo and hawkish White House national security adviser John
Bolton.
“All these results were no doubt
intended by Pompeo and Bolton, and work together with the economic
warfare the administration is waging against Iran, which is aimed at
provoking internal unrest i nside the country that could ultimately lead
to a toppling of clerical rule,” wrote Miller and Sokolsky.
“The imposition of the total embargo on Iranian oil exports, if
successful, will inflict even more economic misery on the Iranian people,
hardening the perception that the U.S. government is an enemy not only of
the ruling regime but also of the Iranian people — an attitude that will
make it harder to ratchet down hostility toward America in the future.”